Collier sheriff renews push to solve 2007 Immokalee arson fire that killed five

A trailer fire early Sunday, March 4, 2007 at 713 Second Ave. in Immokalee killed three children and their mother. The fire broke out while the family was apparently asleep. Dozens of neighbors came out to see the destruction first hand.

Photo by MICHEL FORTIER, Daily News // Buy this photo

A trailer fire early Sunday, March 4, 2007 at 713 Second Ave. in Immokalee killed three children and their mother. The fire broke out while the family was apparently asleep. Dozens of neighbors came out to see the destruction first hand.

Trailer fire settlement

video

Video from YouTube

— Detective Andy Henchesmoore is stumped.

More than three years after someone started an Immokalee trailer on fire, killing five of the 10 people inside, the case is stalled.

Henchesmoore doesn’t have a motive. He doesn’t have a suspect. Four of the five survivors have left town.

Worst of all, nobody is calling with tips.

“I haven’t gotten a single lead in the last two years,” Henchesmoore said. “Not one.”

The Sheriff’s Office is featuring the arson fire as part of a renewed effort to raise awareness of some of its unsolved homicides. The move comes on the heels of a recent Scripps Howard News Service and Daily News series focusing on unsolved homicides in Southwest Florida and across the country.

Sheriff's video regarding the unsolved fatal fire in 2007 at an Immokalee trailer

Henchesmoore believes that someone, somewhere has information that could lead to a break in the case. He just needs that person to come forward.

“This is one of those ones that I keep going back to. I’ve never stopped working it,” Henchesmoore said. “You bang your head against the wall sometimes trying to figure out what the next step is.”

The fire erupted around 2:30 a.m. on March 4, 2007, inside the small, brown trailer on lot 18 of Cleve’s Trailer Park, 713 Second Ave. It took less than a minute for the flames to rip through the entire structure.

Five people were killed in the blaze: Emiliano Lopez Figaroa, 27; Adalmo Granado Ramos, 21; Pascuala Mendez, 34; and Mendez’s 15-year-old daughter, Luciana Vasquez, and 6-year-old son, Rodrigo Carrillo.

Among the five survivors was Mendez’s then 16-year-old son, Wilder Vasquez, who Immokalee firefighters pulled from the flames.

Friends and family members initially though Wilder was killed. In fact, he was burned so badly that it took weeks for family members to identify him.

Wilder spent months in the hospital. When he was finally released, he had to wear protective fabric to cover his healing skin, and had to relearn how to walk and write with a badly burned hand.

Wilder, now 19, continues to live with his aunt and uncle, Juana and Pascual Vasquez, in Immokalee. This spring he graduated from Immokalee High School.

Wilder Vasquez, 16, looks at a picture of himself before he was severely burned in a fire at his Immokalee trailer in March. Vasquez spent four months in hospitals in Tampa and Cincinatti recovering from his injuries. His mother, sister, and brother all died in the fire that was classified as arson. Lexey Swall/Staff

Photo by LEXEY SWALL // Buy this photo

Wilder Vasquez, 16, looks at a picture of himself before he was severely burned in a fire at his Immokalee trailer in March. Vasquez spent four months in hospitals in Tampa and Cincinatti recovering from his injuries. His mother, sister, and brother all died in the fire that was classified as arson. Lexey Swall/Staff

“Thank God that he is doing well,” said Wilder’s aunt, Juana Vasquez, 40, adding that three years later her nephew is better able to care for himself. “When he got out (of the hospital) we had to help him do everything.”

He’s now in Guatemala visiting his grandparents for the summer, she said. It’s the first time he’s been able to travel since the fire.

Vasquez said she is glad the Sheriff’s Office is highlighting her nephew’s case and hopes they catch the culprit.

It’s been awhile since law enforcement officials visited the family’s Immokalee home, Vasquez said.

“Since about a year after it happened, I haven’t heard from them,” she said.

Henchesmoore said he tries not to drop by too often, so as not to give the family false hope.

Arson cases are difficult in general, Henchesmoore said, because the fire burns much of the evidence, and then hundreds of gallons of water from the fire hoses tend to wash away whatever is left.

“Fires like that are always frustrating for us because we can’t go in and rebuild things,” he said.

This one has proven particularly difficult, occurring in a community where people tend to want to mind their own business and not get involved, Henchesmoore said.

What he does know is that around that same time period, there was a streak of arson fires in Immokalee — most were set in trash bins around town. And there were at least two other arson fires at the trailer.

If you have information about these or any other unsolved homicides in Southwest Florida, contact your local law enforcement agency.

■ Collier County Sheriff’s Office — (239) 252-9300

■ Lee County Sheriff’s Office — (239) 477-1000

■ Naples Police and Fire Department — (239) 213-4844

■ Marco Island Police Department — (239) 389-5050

■ Fort Myers Police Department — (239) 321-7700

■ Crime Stoppers — 1-800-780-TIPS (8477)

One of those fires was set in a car parked outside the trailer. The man suspected of starting that fire was in jail at the time of the deadly fire and is not considered a suspect. The other fire, which was set on the trailer itself, may be connected, however.

Also, the night of the deadly fire, someone set a fire in a trash bin at a nearby gas station, Henchesmoore said.

“It could have been diversionary, or if it was an actual arsonist, it could have just been them lighting something else on fire,” he said.

Henchesmoore said he’s not ruling anything out. The fire could have been the work of an arsonist randomly starting fires, but two fires at one trailer leads Henchesmoore to believe the trailer was targeted.

But who was the target?

Mendez still had a husband living in Guatemala, but investigators determined he was still there at the time of the fire. People were subletting rooms in the trailer, and moving in and out all the time, so it’s possible the target wasn’t even living there.

No one who was living in the trailer at the time of the fire appears to have had any gang or drug connections, Henchesmoore said.

“They seemed to me that these were kind of migrant workers just getting by,” Henchesmoore said. “Nothing pointed that they were doing anything illicit. ... They were human beings.

“You can’t put a value on one human being over another.”

* * * * *

Anyone with information about this case is asked to call the Collier County Sheriff’s Office at (239) 793-9300, or call Crime Stoppers at (800) 780-TIPS (8477) to remain anonymous.

SHERIFF KEVIN RAMBOSK'S COLD CASES INITIATIVE

Collier sheriff launches unsolved homicide initiative with 2007 Golden Gate slaying

COLD CASE CHRONICLES SERIES

SOUTHWEST FLORIDA

Cold Case Chronicles: Emotions strong decades later for Collier victims’ relatives (part 2)

Cold Case Chronicles: Parents grieve, await arrest years after children slain in Lee (part 2)

Cold Case Chronicles: Everglades body dump, Miami drug wars drove up Collier murder rate

Cold Case Chronicles: Retired Collier homicide detective ‘persistence is the key’

Cold Case Chronicles: Skeletal remains, mum witnesses challenge detectives in Lee

Cold Case Chronicles: She’s not a Lee deputy, but solving cold cases is her mission

THE STATE AND NATION

Cold Case Chronicles:Murders more likely to go unsolved in Florida’s major cities

Cold Case Chronicles: In a third of U.S. homicides, killer gets away with murder

Cold Case Chronicles: U.S. murders often get solved along racial, age lines

Cold Case Chronicles: Relative considers taking justice into his own hands

Cold Case Chronicles: Some U.S. police departments fail to report murder case status

Cold Case Chronicles: One in nine Americans knows victim of unsolved homicide

Cold Case Chronicles: Many ‘best practices’ improve homicide investigations

© 2010 Naples Daily News. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss
  • Print

Related Stories

Related Links

Comments » 6

angelito writes:

in response to 10PointBuck:

(This comment was removed by the site staff.)

maybe you need to stop making a joke out of it.i sense you have no feeling for human life huh??if you know something we don't know might as well call ccso.....

savethewhalz writes:

"Detective Andy Henchesmoore is stumped." Andy, If this one's too hard, I've got a no brainer cold case that can get you fired or make you a hero. Solve the Terrence Williams and Felipe Santo's disappearances. http://www.sptimes.com/2005/05/29/new....

pauls writes:

in response to savethewhalz:

"Detective Andy Henchesmoore is stumped." Andy, If this one's too hard, I've got a no brainer cold case that can get you fired or make you a hero. Solve the Terrence Williams and Felipe Santo's disappearances. http://www.sptimes.com/2005/05/29/new....

If you're so capable of taking care of unsolved crimes, why are you not dealing with this? How soon should CCSO expect to hear from you with the name of the guilty party?

barefootmike writes:

5 less illeagals, case closed.

Hollywoody writes:

Jerk

0U812 writes:

in response to barefootmike:

5 less illeagals, case closed.

I doubt people will value your post as being credible if you can't spell "illeagals"

Want to participate in the conversation? Become a subscriber today. Subscribers can read and comment on any story, anytime. Non-subscribers will only be able to view comments on select stories.

Cold Case Chronicles

Features